IFRS 9 Expected Credit Losses: The New Credit Loss Model Made Simple

The answer lies in the IFRS 9 Expected Credit Losses (ECL) model – a topic that might sound complicated but is essential for any professional looking to climb the corporate ladder.

IFRS 9 is an International Financial Reporting Standard that replaced the older IAS 39 standard. It changed how financial institutions classify and measure financial assets, introducing a more forward-looking approach to credit loss recognition.

But why should you care?

Well, if you're working in finance, understanding IFRS 9 can:

• Boost your career prospects by adding a valuable technical skill to your resume
• Improve your decision-making when dealing with financial instruments
• Help you better understand your company's financial health
• Make you stand out from colleagues who might be intimidated by these concepts

Expected Credit Loss Model: The Basics

Remember the 2008 financial crisis?

One of the biggest criticisms afterwards was that banks recognised loan losses too late. The old "incurred loss" model only allowed companies to account for losses after they happened.

IFRS 9 changed this with its Expected Credit Loss model, which requires companies to prepare for potential future losses.

Think of it like weather forecasting. The old model was like waiting until it rained to get an umbrella. The new ECL model is like checking the forecast and bringing an umbrella when there's a chance of rain.

IFRS 9 Stage 1,2,3: The Three Stages of Expected Credit Losses

IFRS 9 introduces a three-stage approach to recognising expected credit losses. Let's break these down:

Stage 1: “12-month expected credit losses” (The Honeymoon Phase)

When a loan is first issued, it typically falls into Stage 1. Here, banks assume the borrower will repay, but they still need to account for possible losses over the next 12 months. These losses are calculated using a probability-weighted credit loss formula and discounted at the effective interest rate.

• You recognise potential losses that could occur in the next 12 months
• Interest revenue is then calculated on the actual gross carrying amount of the asset
• Most loans start here when they're new and performing well

Example: Imagine you're a bank that just issued a $100,000 mortgage to a customer with excellent credit. Based on historical data and economic forecasts, you estimate there's a 0.5% chance this loan might default in the next 12 months, resulting in a 40% loss. Your 12-month ECL would be $100,000 × 0.5% × 40% = $200.

Stage 2: Lifetime Expected Credit Losses (The Warning Signs)

If the borrower’s credit risk significantly increases but hasn’t defaulted yet, the loan moves to Stage 2. Now, instead of looking at only 12 months, banks must calculate expected credit losses over the entire remaining life of the loan.

• You now recognise lifetime expected credit losses
• Interest revenue is still to be calculated on the gross carrying amount
• The provision increases, reflecting the higher risk

Example: Six months later, that mortgage customer loses their job. They're still making payments, but the risk has clearly increased. You now calculate expected losses over the entire 30-year life of the loan, not just 12 months. If you estimate a 5% chance of default over the loan's lifetime with the same 40% loss severity, your ECL would increase to $100,000 × 5% × 40% = $2,000.

Since risk has increased, the bank recognises a higher expected loss.

Stage 3: Lifetime Expected Credit Losses on Amortised Cost (Houston, We Have a Problem)

When a borrower actually defaults or shows clear signs of non-repayment, the loan is classified under Stage 3. The key difference here? The effective interest rate is applied to the amortised cost, not the gross carrying amount.

• You continue to recognise lifetime expected credit losses
• Interest revenue is now calculated on the amortised cost (gross carrying amount minus loss allowance)
• This is similar to the old "incurred loss" model

Why the Three-Stage Approach Matters

You might be wondering, "Why go through all this trouble?"

For financial institutions, IFRS 9’s ECL model ensures proactive risk management. Instead of waiting for defaults, banks adjust their balance sheets in real-time. This shift helps prevent financial crises by forcing institutions to acknowledge risks early on.

According to the European Central Bank (ECB), banks must ensure that their IFRS 9 models accurately reflect risk and avoid underestimating potential losses.

Here, we see how the three-stage approach offers several benefits:

1. Earlier recognition of potential losses helps banks maintain healthier balance sheets
2. More transparent financial reporting gives investors better information
3. Better risk management encourages more prudent lending practices
4. Smoother recognition of losses over time rather than sudden large write-offs

Challenges in Implementing IFRS 9 ECL

Let's be honest – implementing IFRS 9 isn't a walk in the park. Here are some key challenges:

1. Volatility in Financial Statements: The transition from incurred losses (IAS 39) to expected losses (IFRS 9) means that banks report losses sooner. This can lead to significant fluctuations in financial statements, especially during economic downturns.

2. Increased Capital Requirements: Since higher provisions reduce a bank’s profit, financial institutions need to hold more capital as a buffer against unexpected losses. Regulators closely monitor these changes to ensure stability in the financial system.

3. Judgment & Model Complexity: IFRS 9 requires banks to develop complex models for predicting future credit losses. This means accountants and risk managers must continuously refine their assumptions and inputs.

Real-World Impact of IFRS 9 ECL

How does IFRS 9 affect financial institutions in practice? When the standard was first implemented, many banks saw their loan loss provisions increase by 20-40%. This had a direct impact on:

• Regulatory capital ratios
• Profitability metrics
• Volatility in financial results

During the COVID-19 pandemic, IFRS 9 was put to the test as banks needed to rapidly reassess expected credit losses in light of unprecedented economic disruption. Many institutions had to significantly increase their provisions, highlighting both the forward-looking nature of the standard and the challenges in making reliable forecasts during uncertain times.

Tips for Managing These Changes

If you're working with IFRS 9 in your organisation, here's a summary of some practical tips:

1. Understand the big picture – know why the standard exists and what it's trying to achieve
2. Pay attention to assumptions – small changes in default probability or loss severity can have big impacts
3. Consider multiple scenarios – don't rely on a single economic forecast
4. Documentation is key – clearly document your reasoning for significant judgments
5. Stay updated – regulatory guidance and best practices continue to evolve

The Future of Credit Loss Accounting: How to Stay Ahead

IFRS 9 represents a major shift in how we think about credit losses, but it's likely not the final word. As technology advances, we can expect the following:

• More sophisticated machine learning models for loss prediction
• Better integration of alternative data sources
• More real-time updates to expected loss calculations

The standard will continue to evolve as regulators and standard-setters learn from implementation experiences.

Understanding IFRS 9 Expected Credit Losses isn't just about compliance – it's about developing a skill that's increasingly valued in the financial services industry. As banks and financial institutions continue to invest in improving their ECL methodologies, professionals who can bridge the gap between accounting standards and practical implementation will be in high demand.

By mastering these concepts, you position yourself as someone who understands both the regulatory requirements and the business implications – a combination that can help you stand out in a competitive job market.

Ready to deepen your IFRS knowledge?

If you're looking to take your IFRS 9 knowledge to the next level and gain a competitive edge in your finance career, we offer comprehensive IFRS 9 workshops designed specifically for finance professionals like you.

Our expert-led training programs will help you master complex concepts like Expected Credit Losses in a practical, accessible way, giving you the confidence to apply these skills in your daily work:

• Make better lending decisions
• Improve financial risk management
• Enhance regulatory compliance

Explore our IFRS courses today and take the next step in your career advancement!

FAQ

Is ECL the same as impairment?

No, Expected Credit Losses (ECL) under IFRS 9 is not the same as impairment, but they are related. ECL is a forward-looking measure that estimates potential credit losses over time, even before a default occurs. Impairment, on the other hand, refers to the actual recognition of a loss when there is objective evidence that a financial asset is impaired. IFRS 9 replaces the old incurred loss model with the ECL model, ensuring that losses are recognised earlier rather than waiting for evidence of impairment.